Singapore’s Kelong Boleh?

The Agri-Food and Veterinary Authority (AVA) wants to improve Singapore’s food self-sufficiency. There are more than 100 fish farms in Singapore producing 8 per cent of our total fish consumption. The agency is helping these farms boost their productivity so that their market share can increase to 15 per cent.

I speak to Bryan of Ah Hua Kelong at their coastal farm in Lorong Halus jetty to find out if they are ready to increase production, and how they are dealing with the plankton blooms, the competitive import prices and their own limited output.

This 10-year-old kelong set up by two army friends with a fishing enthusiast is about 4 acres. The cages that carry fishes below 500 grams each are sheltered because smaller fishes are more vulnerable to drastic changes in weather.

This 10-year-old kelong set up by two army friends and a fishing enthusiast is about 4 acres. The farm rears mainly barramundi, pearl grouper and mussels. The cages in the picture are sheltered because the fishes kept inside are under 500 grams each and are more vulnerable to weather changes.

Barramundi, also known as Asian sea bass. The kelong used to sell mainly to the restaurants, but their demand for fishes between the narrow range of 900 grams to 1.1 kilograms is hard to meet, says Bryan, given how fishes grow at different speed despite the same rearing conditions. Today, Ah Hua is one of the few fish farms that offer free home deliveries to boost their B2C sales.

The kelong used to sell mainly to the restaurants, but their specific request for fishes between the narrow range of 900 grams to 1.1 kilograms is hard to meet, says Bryan. Fishes grow at different rates even in the same rearing conditions. Since last year, Ah Hua offers free home deliveries to boost their B2C sales.

They catch wild flower and mud crabs too. Even then, the seafood variety they offer is limited compared to the traditional wet markets where the imports are sold.

They also catch flower and mud crabs from the wild. Even then, their varieties are far from the range of imported seafood. Singaporean consumers who have been spoiled for choices are more likely to buy from the markets, where the entire range of available seafood are sold. The ideal scenario is if the consumers prioritise local supplies, and buy from amongst the imports whatever that is not available from the local farms.

Ah Hua feeds the smaller fishes pellets made of soy beans and fish oil. According to Bryan, the AVA permits slaughter house waste as fish feed, a common practice in the fishing industry. However, he believes the waste contributes a muddy flavour to their fishes, which he doesn't want.

Ah Hua feeds pellets made of soy beans and fish oil to the younger fishes. These are “slow-sinking” pellets that the fishes can get to before they sink through the nets. It is a common practice to use slaughter house waste for fish feed. According to Bryan, AVA permits this practice, but he believes such feeds bring out an undesirable muddy flavour in the meat.

The kelong buys wild caught small fishes to feed the bigger fishes in their farms.

The kelong buys wild catches to feed the bigger fishes in their farms.

Bryan says the wild caught feed is fresh enough even for human consumption.

Bryan says they are fit for human consumption.

The workers run the feed through a grinder to help the smaller-sized fishes better digest the feed. Bryan says the kelong, as with most others, do not feed its fishes antibiotics nor vaccinate them, even though AVA permits such practice. "Even if we use, our prices also can't compete with overseas supply," he says. Vaccines and antibiotics would have helped reduce the death rate, which is currently at 30 per cent.

The workers grind the feed to help the smaller-sized fishes better digest them. The kelong, as with most others in Singapore, says Bryan, does not feed its fishes antibiotics nor vaccinate them. Vaccines and antibiotics would help reduce the death rate, which is now at 30 per cent, but that would rule out the kelong’s option to export to the markets that ban these additives.

The cost of running the fish farm mainly falls on the cost of the diet plan ($1 for 1 kilogram feed), the labour...

The bulk of the cost of running the fish farm is in the feed and the foreign worker levy, says Bryan. Fish farms in the neighbouring countries benefit from lower labour cost and their ability to purchase the feed in bulk and at cheaper prices.

"Ah Min," as his employers call him, is a Myanmese who has been working with them for more than a year. Bryan says it's impossible to get Singaporeans to work and live in a kelong.

Foreign workers, like Ah Min, a Burmese who has been working at Ah Hua for over a year, are essential to Singapore’s food self-sufficiency. They feed the fishes…

Clean the nets regularly to ensure good water circulation, otherwise wastes will build up within the cages and the fish will develop a muddy taste.

… Clean the nets regularly to ensure the water circulates well, or wastes will build up inside the cages and the fishes will develop a muddy taste.

Bryan rears lobsters, which feeds on mussels, to clean off the ones growing on the fish nets.

After all there are only one or two dozens of lobsters to clean off the mussels growing on the fish nets…

When it rains too regularly, Bryan says, water salinity and temperature drops. To keep their saltwater fishes alive, the workers will lower the nets deeper into the sea, where the water is less affected by the change in weather conditions.

… And when it rains too regularly, water salinity and temperature drop. To keep the saltwater fishes alive, Ah Yong (left), the kelong’s Thai worker, will have to work in the rain and lower the nets deeper into the sea, where the water is less affected by the changes in weather conditions.

If no young Singaporeans will be hawker assistants, it is hard to imagine anyone accepting such backward living condition, with little privacy and plenty of fish odour.

If no young Singaporeans would be hawker assistants, it is even more unlikely they will accept such living condition, where there is little comfort and plenty of fish odour.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

While the high production cost translates to a high selling price, local fishes arrive at the markets fresher than the imports due to proximity; the stringent checks that local authorities put in place also ensure good farming practices. Bryan (right) jokes that AVA visits them more than he wants them to — at least once a month.

Plankton bloom, a rapid accumulation of algae in the sea, began to hit the coastal farms less than five years ago. The planktons consume oxygens from the water, suffocating the fishes. With financial assistance from the AVA, the kelong bought an aerator to increase dissolved oxygen in the water when the bloom happens in the dry months.

Plankton bloom, a rapid accumulation of algae in the sea, first hit the coastal farms less than five years ago. The planktons consume oxygens from the water, suffocating the fishes. With financial assistance from the AVA, the kelong has bought an aerator to increase oxygen supply in the water during the dry months when the bloom occurs.

Kelongs keep dogs to alert the owners or worker to the intruders.

Although pet dogs alert farm owners to intruders, the list does not include planktons.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *